Season 3-Episode 02

Queen’s Landing

If this be a victory, I pray I never have another

Lord Corlys Velaryon

Observations from a Book Reader

  1. Rhaenyra never ordered the execution of her own Queensguard, Ser Lorent Marbrand. He did die shortly after this though. But she never ordered him killed because Lorent never directly disobeyed an order like we saw him do last week. His death in the show was offscreen and we only know it happened because Rhaenyra said “Let Ser Lorent choose how he will die”. Then this guy also had the balls to lay his hands on the Queen. Worst knight of all time.
  2. Since Jace died on her orders, not due to his own defiance, Rhaenyra’s anger was more internalized and led to her appearing more mad to those around her. The show is taking a different path with Rhaenyra and her grief. We see Rhaena hiding in the Vale before Rhaenyra can find out her actions (or lack thereof) in the battle, and this caution would be justified as after the death of Jace, Rhaenyra’s paranoia of other dragonriders knew no bounds and included Nettles, the dragonrider that the TV show version of Rhaena is replacing.
  3. Corlys petitioned Rhaenyra for her to legitimize his 2 sons, Addam and Alyn. He then named the former his heir as in the books, Addam was the elder and the one dragonrider. Alyn did attempt to claim Sheepstealer at one point but it ended in him almost getting barbecued.
  4. Time to address the biggest divergence this week.,The Fall of King’s Landing. Alicent had no part to play in this fight, she never conspired with the Gold Cloaks or other members of the city council to allow Rhaenyra entry. Instead, Rhaenyra and Daemon flew in on Syrax and Caraxes as soon as they heard Aemond left the city, while the Sea Snake escorted his entire fleet up Blackwater Bay. The Gold Cloaks turned on the Greens as soon as they saw Caraxes in the sky (see O.P.T.N. note 4 for why), and slaughtered the captains in charge of the city’s defense. This of course means Daemon never walked through the Red Keep by himself killing everyone in front of him, as they had an actual military there with them. That does not make good TV I suppose. Rhaenyra was also not the one to behead Otto (or any other prisoner). During this fight, Aegon and Larys fled the capital, but in the show they left long ago. Helaena never attempted to run, but was never put in any danger as she was completely ruined by the death of her infant son Jaehaerys and apolitical the rest of her brief life.
  5. MAJOR BOOK SPOILER AHEAD THIS LINE: One thing I am extremely disappointed about in this episode: when Rhaenyra sat upon the throne for the first time she did not visibly cut her hand. In Game of Thrones, Joffrey also never cut his hand on the throne as the throne in that show looked far more blunt and innocent than its book counterpart. However House of the Dragon radically changed the appearance of the throne and made it look more how it was originally envisioned by GRRM. I thought this was the perfect opportunity to correct an old mistake and introduce the significance of a ruler cutting themselves. It was a long storied Westerosi folk tale that any who cut themselves upon the throne were being rejected by the throne. Most notably Maegor the Cruel appeared to have died from multiple cuts from the Iron Throne. Rhaenyra cutting herself quickly became a rumor among the smallfolk and ultimately led them to look at her with scorn and disrespect.
  6. Rhaenyra’s uncertainty and apprehension climbing the throne is so different than her behavior in the book. After Jace’s death she was so obsessed with winning that it made her seem maniacal. She certainly would not be crying as she executed the man responsible for all the conflict in the civil war. She ordered the deaths of everyone who she felt betrayed by as soon as she walked into the Red Keep.

Other Points to Notice

  1. We finally get some new additions to the opening tapestry title sequence. We see Corlys fighting Admiral Lohar, and in the next one Jace in the fetal position pincushioned with arrows.
  2. Addam, Ulf, and Hugh arrive to clean up the remaining ships at the Gullet. Even though they were there from the beginning in the text, and Sheepstealer was never around. It does lead to a very humorous scene of Daemon reprimanding Ulf, who tried to hug Daemon when he saw him (seriously, rewatch this scene it’s so funny). Someone described the character of Ulf in this show as a person from contemporary times thrown into Westeros and once you see it, it’s hard to unsee how hilarious it is.
  3. We briefly see a woman celebrating with Daemon and his men in the Riverlands. This woman is almost certainly Alysanne Blackwood, the woman in charge of House Blackwood and a fierce loyalist to the Blacks. Try to remember her name, as she should be important by the end of this show.
  4. Luthor Largent, the man that Alicent meets with to negotiate the city guard’s surrender to the Blacks, is the head of the Gold Cloaks. In case anyone forgot, the Gold Cloaks are essentially the police of King’s Landing, and operate outside the authority of the Whitecloaks, who only care about protecting the royal family. In Season 1, Daemon was the commander of the Gold Cloaks, and was beloved by all of them for his leadership style and for being a member of the royal family who interacted with the common folk. Almost all of them remained Daemon loyalists and jumped at the chance to rejoin his side.
  5. Daemon brings up “The Song of Ice and Fire” to a grieving Rhaenyra. Much as been said on this show-only prophecy, but it does provide a good reason for why Daemon now seems so committed to Rhaenyra ascending the throne. He even mentions a girl with silver hair, who of course viewers will know to be Daenerys. Even though it was Arya that ultimately killed the Night King, she never gets the chance without Dany’s dragons helping the fight.
  6. After Daemon spurned the witch Alys Rivers, she has one of the most powerful men in Westeros at her mercy after Aemond was stabbed killing the Strong family. Surely she wont leverage this situation to her advantage.
  7. Larys appeared to keep Otto Hightower buried so deep in the black cells that not even the other Greens (including his 2 children) knew about it. His reasoning for doing this is suspect though, and I imagine it was just him playing both sides in case the fortunes reversed.
A much angrier Rhaenyra Targaryen, sitting on the Iron Throne

Stray Observations:

  1. Did anyone else notice that the opening title was slightly remixed? They added much more bass and stronger drums to the background. I thought it sounded great, I wish they started the show doing this.
  2. The scene of Daemon, Oscar Tully, and Roddy the Ruin singing after a victory felt very reminiscent of the tone of A Knight of Seven Kingdoms.
  3. Daemon and Simon Strong are the best pair in the show so far. Sad we won’t get anymore.
  4. Aegon and Larys are heading to Rook’s Rest, the fortress where Aegon was injured and his dragon Sunfyre “died”.
  5. The scene of Jasper attempting to rape Alicent felt pointless and cruel for really no reason. I’m sure there are other articles that go into it better than I could here though.
  6. Harrenhal already looks like a charred ruin because Balerion the Black Dread once melted it during Aegon’s Conquest. Now his sister Vhagar gets to do the same.
  7. Love him or hate him, Otto going out talking shit to Rhaenyra was incredible. If you want more Rhys Ifans though, he is currently starring in the incredible Apple TV show, Star City.
  8. Daemon is still a bastard, but he has had some undeniable character growth, especially as a loyal believer in his Queen.
  9. I’m really not looking forward to the inevitable plot line this season between Alicent and Rhaenyra. “How could you kill my poor father! You said you would take over the city and kill all my sons peacefully!!” bleh

RIP: Lord Simon Strong and sons, Master of Laws Jasper “Ironrod” Wylde, Lord Otto Hightower, Ser Lorent Marbrand

Season 3-Episode 01

Salt and Sea, Fire and Blood

We have come to die for the Dragon Queen

Ser Roderick Dustin

Observations from a Book Reader

  1. I brought this up last season, but Sheepstealer was claimed by a small peasant girl named Nettles, and not Rhaena Velaryon. Rhaena seems to just have fully taken the place of Nettles at this point, which may have interesting implications later on.
  2. Aemond never declared himself King when Aegon was unable to sit the throne. Even after Aegon disappeared he was only ever referred to as Prince Regent. Show Aemond is certainly more power hungry, but even in the books Aemond was said to have stated that the crown looked better on himself than it ever did on Aegon.
  3. The dragonseeds (the 3 new dragonriders, Ulf the White, Hugh Hammer, Addam of Hull) did not go to the God’s Eye (lake outside Harrenhal) and wait for Aemond to arrive. Their first taste of the war was actually the Battle of the Gullet that is later in this episode. They helped turn back the Triarchy fleet but were largely undisciplined and out of control in the fury of battle. Odd choice to instead sideline them this episode.
  4. There were no incestual undertones in the relationship between Aemond and Alicent. But this relationship in general was largely unexplored and unimportant, as Alicent matters far more in the show than she did in the book story at this point. From the behind the scenes look, it seems like Aemond has always been so desperate for his mothers love (recall how little Alicent seemed to care for her children in season 1), that it created some warped Oedipus complex paired with the already warped Targaryen sense of family. Alicent also seemed to be disgusted. Aemond’s decision to attack Daemon at Harrenhal was his own idea in Fire and Blood
  5. Time to get to the single largest change from the books in this episode. Recall that Rhaenyra and Daemon had 3 children together. Aegon (yes another Aegon), Viserys, and Joffrey. Last season, they were all sent to the Vale with Rhaena, where Joffrey would remain and the other two would be sent to safety across the sea in Pentos. This is where things diverge greatly, as the journey to Pentos was what started the Battle of the Gullet in the text. While on board the ship Gay Abandon (named after Laenor Velaryon leaving his children I’m sure) Aegon and Viserys found themselves under siege by the Triarchy fleet. Aegon who was 9 at this point, was forced to abandon his brother and fly his dragon Stormcloud back to Dragonstone. From there Rhaenyra sent Jace and the dragonseeds to assist Corlys in fighting off the Triarchy. The rest of the battle played out largely the same, with Jace and Vermax dying, and the Triarchy sacking Hightide (home of Corlys Velaryon). After the battle there was no trace of Aegon’s brother Viserys or the ship they set out on. This introduces some interesting differences in the show since as far as we have seen, Aegon, Viserys, and Joffrey are all still at the Eyrie.

Other Points to Notice

  1. The man who captures Aegon and Larys is a member of House Staunton. They are not of much consequence, but their home is Rook’s Rest, the same stronghold we saw attacked by the Greens last season. It was during this battle that Rhaenys was killed by Aemond, and Aegon was nearly burnt to death.
  2. Daemon’s army was fighting in the westerlands when they ran into the Stark soldiers. At one point you see a soldier chopping off the head of an actual lion. Casterly Rock used to be home to many lion’s and the Lannister’s clearly thought they were the masters of them. By the time of GoT only captive lions remain in the area and are not really relevant to anything going on.
  3. The Stark’s purposely sent “Greybeards” to aid Rhaenyra. It is a longstanding tradition in the North that before winter arrived, the old and infirm would leave the safety of their keeps and “fend for themselves” in the frozen snows. When Roderick Dustin (actual nickname is Roddy the Ruin) says that they have come to die for the dragon queen, he is being literal. Winter’s are so harsh in the north the old sacrifice themselves so the food and shelter can go to the younger generation. This is what makes these old men such great fighters, they don’t care if they die.
  4. I have a feeling that to non book readers, the scene in which we meet Ormund Hightower would be the most confusing, as it contains several large players who have only been mentioned by name thus far. They are all extremely important to the rest of the show so try to take note here and I’ll address the new characters in order of their appearance.
    • Tessarion– The scene begins with us seeing a medium sized blue dragon but no rider. This dragon is Tessarion the dragon of Daeron Targaryen. Daeron is the youngest son of Alicent and Viserys, younger brother to Aegon and Aemond. While he HAS been mentioned before on the show, it was very brief and his only actual appearance was in the closing montage of last season when we caught a brief glimpse of him flying across the sky (check my S2E08 recap for more info).
    • Ormund Hightower– The lord of Oldtown, one of the single most powerful men in Westeros. His Uncle is the old hand of the King, Otto Hightower, which makes Queen Alicent and Gwayn Hightower his cousins. He commands a host of over 1000 fully armed knights
    • “Bold” Jon Roxton- Ormunds second in command, and an extremely deadly warrior. He is one of the few lords to own a Valyrian steel sword aptly named Orphan-Maker.
    • Daeron Targaryen????- Ormund’s squire, who has little to say in this scene, is almost certainly our first real look at Daeron Targaryen. We know that Daeron is the squire of Ormund, and we see the dragon in the camp, so this young red-head must be Daeron. Daeron did have the distinct hair and eyes of the Targaryens in the books, but maybe the show is trying to set up a surprise for non book readers. Sorry for spoiling if that’s the case but what are you doing reading a book accurate blog if you care that much about the tv show being your source for canon. Come on guys.
  5. I can forgive a lot in the show breaking from the books, but having a sworn member of the Queensguard ignore the direct order of his sovereign was almost my breaking point. That would defeat the entire purpose of the Queensguard if other members of the royal family could supercede the command of the queen/king.
The death of Prince Jacaerys Velaryon

Stray Observations:

  1. When Larys and Aegon’s identities were revealed to House Staunton, it seemed a bit much that the man in charge would go to kill them when the game of hostages is always how business is done in Westeros, especially when your hostage is as valuable as Aegon and Larys would be.
  2. Rhaenyra’s belief in Alicent is borderline insane. Not that she trusts Alicent, but that she trusts in her competence to control her own children to the extent needed for her plan to work.
  3. Gwayn and Cole discussing punishing a soldier really shows us that Cole is continuing his weird nihilist attitude this season
  4. Come on Alyn, Corlys is trying to be your dad now because you’re a great asset on his ship. Time to forgive 30 years of absence.
  5. Sharako Lohar has to be one of my top 3 least favorite HBO GoT universe characters. Bad acting, and just a cartoon like quality to her that makes no sense in a show like this.
  6. Did you catch the weird glimpse of a person in some druid garb before Alys Rivers appeared to the rest of the dragonseeds? At least she admitted to them that she is a witch, after season 2 there was little doubt. Something strange is going on in the area around Harrenhal.
  7. The navigation scene was awesome and filmed brilliantly, as well as the ship to ship combat. No notes.
  8. Alyn really just called Corlys “father” in front of all of those soldiers smh.

RIP: Lord Jason Lannister, Ser Tyland Lannister, Sharako Lohar, Prince Jacaerys Velaryon

Season 2-Episode 08

The Queen Who Ever Was

The dragons dance, and men are like dust under their feet. And all our fine thoughts, all our endeavors are as nothing.

Ser Criston Cole

Observations from a Book Reader

  1. The people of Tyrosh, the Tyroshi, were known for dyeing their hair blue. The most famous Tyroshi to book/show fans is Daario Naharis, but Game of Thrones removed his iconic blue hair and forked beard. In this episode’s scenes with Tyland Lannister we finally see some weird blue hair. Further note, Lohar was a male in the book.
  2. Larys did help Aegon escape King’s Landing, but he did not go with him. Larys remained in the city hiding within its secret tunnels and passages. Aegon’s remaining 2 children (only 1 child left in the show) were also sent to different places for safety. Another difference is that Aegon only fled because Rhaenyra was on her way to take the city, not because of fear of his brother.
  3. Rhaena does eventually claim a dragon, but it is a hatchling from one of the eggs she brought to the Vale, not Sheepstealer.
  4. Cole and Gawyn never got in a confrontation, because Cole did not sleep with Alicent in the book. This scene felt out of place to me, how did Gawyn figure out his sister and Cole were having an affair? There was no set up to this, and it seems odd Gawyn would wait so long to bring this up. I wonder if this was a cut scene from an earlier episode that they added to the finale to give Cole a final scene before the next two year wait.
  5. Daemon’s vision of the future never occurred in the book. Some of the things he sees in this scene are odd to say the least. He sees a man with an antler helmet by a weirwood, a possible reference to the Green Men who were said to live in the weirwood grove on an island on the lake by Harrenhal, called the God’s Eye (more on this below). He also sees a man with a mark on his face, and the Three Eyed Raven. This would be Brynden “Bloodraven” Rivers, a descendant of Daemon’s who eventually becomes the Three Eyed Raven we remember from Game of Thrones. What is strange is that in Game of Thrones, Brynden Rivers did not have this iconic mark on his face when Bran met him north of the Wall. I am not sure if this is a retcon, or perhaps it is a teaser to connect this show to the upcoming A Knight of The Seven Kingdoms, which is coming out before season 3 and will definitely feature Bloodraven in it.
  6. Just as Rhaenyra never went to King’s Landing to see Alicent, Alicent never went to Dragonstone to see Rhaenyra. They were never friends growing up as their ages were too different, Alicent being much older than she is in the show. Alicent agreeing to sacrifice Aegon to end the war is a stark contrast to the Alicent we once saw attack Rhaenyra on behalf of her son Aemond losing an eye. It feels like the writers wanted to strongly re-establish the possible love between her and Rhaenyra.
Brynden Rivers with his weirwood longbow, art by Amok

Other Points to Notice

  1. The final addition to the tapestry in the opening credits, is a depiction of The Red Sowing. We see Vhagar being blocked off by Syrax and six other dragons. Vermax (Jace), Caraxes (Daemon), Moondancer (Baela), Seasmoke (Laenor), Vermithor (Hugh), and Silverwing (Ulf).
  2. When Larys is selling Aegon on his escape plan, he gives him a series of hypothetical names. The last one “The Realm’s Delight” is a name that Rhaenyra used to be called when she was a girl. This is not lost on Aegon as he smiles and seems to enjoy this name the most, since it is a direct mockery of his elder half sister.
  3. I have no idea why we got so many scenes of Rhaena looking for Sheepstealer. It can be summed up as: Rhaena leaves her caravan and finds the dragon she was looking for.
  4. When Alfred Broome is selling Daemon on the idea of claiming the throne for himself, you can audibly here the word “Traitor” spoken in the background, which causes Alfred to look around wondering if someone else was there. I only caught this with subtitles, but since he is by the weirwood tree when this happens, it can be assumed magic or prophecy is involved. Keep an eye on this Broome fella.
  5. Helaena is the first one to outwardly accuse Aemond of the treason he committed against his brother. She also predicts Aegon will become king again, and that Aemond will die in the God’s Eye. The God’s Eye is the name of the lake next to Harrenhal, it is called this because it is shaped like an eye and has an island in it’s center which from above looks like a pupil. This scene also implies Helaena can communicate via weirwood trees like Alys Rivers.
  6. All season Daemon has been having visions of his mistakes and the cost of his ambition to be king. But when he bows to Rhaenyra none of those seem to matter as it is only his vision of the future that makes him fully loyal. The only way to justify the time spent with Daemon in Harrenhal the past seven episodes is that maybe he needed to grow from the first visions before being open to seeing the future and believing the prophecy to be real.
  7. We see a few interesting things in the final montage. First, a blue dragon flying over the Hightower army which must be Daeron Targaryen and his dragon Tessarion, which would be the first time they have been on the show. We also see Otto Hightower in some sort of prison, presumably at the hands of the Beesbury army. They were mentioned last episode as attacking the Hightowers as revenge for the death of Viserys’ hand in season 1, Lyman Beesbury.

Stray Observations:

  1. The line about Aegon’s dick exploding like a sausage on a stick was incredible
  2. Ser Alfred Broome constantly mentions how anti-betrayal he is, and he of course immediately tries to betray Rhaenyra with Daemon.
  3. For some reason Simon Strong sneaking around eavesdropping was the funniest part of this episode to me.
  4. Did we really need to spend a quarter of the finale watching Tyland Lannister’s exploits in Essos? One scene really could have sufficed. Maybe this was to give Lohar some characterization but doing so in the finale is odd. Why not wait until next season?
  5. Jace has been ridiculously moody for too long.
  6. Alyn had a nice speech to Corlys. But I am not sure we are attached to him enough as a character for this emotional moment to really have affect.
  7. The final montage did a great job of changing the music to reflect the armies onscreen. First we get the Stark theme, then the Lannister theme, and finally Daenerys’ theme.
  8. Bold move to end a season with a finale that is practically just a trailer for the next Season.

RIP: All the peasants of Sharp Point.

Season Verdict: Overall I would rate this season a 7/10. There were many high points in character arcs, but also some strange deviations from the source material (why did they kill off Aegon’s dragon Sunfyre???) and really only 1 episode that had any action whatsoever. Last season ended with a promise for war but then this season began with Rhaenyra doing everything she could to not engage in any combat whatsoever. Daemon’s arc really dragged as well, even if the payoff made sense for his character. I could go into way more detail on all my thoughts, but I think my episode summaries made it clear what I did and did not agree with. See you all in 2026 for season 3, where the show-runner Ryan Condal has assured us the largest battle of the series will take place in the first few episodes.

Season 2-Episode 07

The Red Sowing

I never wanted it. I was right not to. All the pain it caused. It crushes whoever wears it. You always wanted it Daemon, do you want it still?

Daemon’s vision of Viserys Targaryen

Observations from a Book Reader

  1. Addam Velaryon was one of the smallfolk who answered Jace’s call to come to Dragonstone to attempt to claim a dragon. Once he did, he was immediately accepted as a dragonrider, there was no confrontation between him and Rhaenyra as there was in this episode. Most believed he was the son of Laenor, but those who knew about Laenor’s love for dudes believed him to be the son of Corlys. Corlys did claim Addam and Alyn to be Laenor’s bastards and used this to get Rhaenyra to legitimize them as Velaryons.
  2. Corlys mentioned how his blood had a lot of Targaryen in it from past generations of Velaryon/Targaryen pairings. The show went a different route and through Corlys’ statement made it sound like Addam’s Targaryen blood and ability to fly a dragon comes from his unknown mother’s side. Unless the show-runners are implying that any random person can become a dragon rider this entire time. But hearing about Hugh’s mother being one of the daughters of King Jaehaerys makes me think Targaryen blood is still necessary.
  3. As I have mentioned before, using smallfolk who may be Targaryen bastards, or dragonseeds as they are called in Fire and Blood, was entirely Jace’s idea. He is vehemently against it in the show, due to some personal angst at being a bastard himself. His reasoning does make sense, as it makes other dragonriders who are also bastards just as legitimate of successors as him, but the book version of this character was bolder and never considered anyone could challenge him.
  4. Hugh’s mother is heavily alluded to be Saera Targaryen. She was the problem child of Jaehaerys and Alysanne Targaryen. By the age of 18 she was forced to join the Faith of the Seven as punishment for several affairs and subsequent scandals in the Red Keep she was involved in. She escaped from the Faith’s control and eventually opened a pleasure house across the Narrow Sea in Lys, where she remained for the rest of her life. When Jaehaerys was on his deathbed he often mistook Alicent Hightower as his daughter Saera, returned from across the sea.
  5. When the dragonseeds attempted to claim dragons, there were 5 that were available. Vermithor, Silverwing, Sheepstealer, Cannibal, and Grey Ghost. This episode only had Vermithor and Silverwing living at Dragonstone. Sheepstealer we can assume is in the show, and is currently being pursued by Rhaena in the Vale, instead of being claimed by Nettles (a mysterious common born girl with dark skin). Alyn of Hull, Addam’s brother, was injured trying to claim Sheepstealer, but his show counterpart does not seem to be interested in dragon riding. Grey Ghost was a small dragon that was extremely skittish and no one was ever able to find or claim him. Cannibal was a gigantic feral dragon that some believed to be nearly as old as Vhagar, and every attempt to claim him was met with death. He was infamous in Dragonstone for eating other baby dragons and generally being an evil menace. Unfortunately it appears that Cannibal and Grey Ghost will not be shown on television.
The Cannibal as depicted by Douglas Wheatley in Fire & Blood

Other Points to Notice

  1. Although it is never said, I would have to assume that when Rhaenyra heard about Seasmoke flying with a rider, she must have thought it was her husband Laenor returned from Essos. The show never addresses it, but at this point we can assume Laenor is dead, since his dragon is accepting a new rider, and we know the relationship between dragon and rider is magical by nature.
  2. Alicent’s scar on her wrist is located in almost the exact same spot as the cut she inflicted upon Rhaenyra in season 1. This was when she was in a rage because her son Aemond had just lost an eye and she demanded recompense.
  3. Larys withholding information from Aemond regarding the new rider of Seasmoke is almost certainly a case of him trying to sabotage Aemond’s reign. Later in the episode we see him encouraging Aegon to heal quickly, because he knows Aegon favors him but Aemond does not. When Aemond flies after Silverwing at the end of the episode, he could have easily walked into an ambush, and if he knew Seasmoke had a rider as well the chances of that ambush happening would be even lower.
  4. I don’t have many notes on Oscar Tully’s meeting with Daemon and the riverlords, other than it was the type of scene that reminds you how great these shows can be. Oscar fully played on the riverlord’s sense of honor, and knew Daemon was completely at his mercy. Something else at play here was the fact that Daemon acquiesced, even after being called Prince. All of the visions he has had of his past regrets and guilt are potentially making him change as a person for the better. This would at least justify the amount of time we have spent viewing his flashbacks
  5. Alicent seems to be going on a vacation to clear her mind? This whole season she has had themes around her about being cleansed of her sins, like when they show her and her constant baths. Her swim this episode is definitely in line with that motif, but I struggle to find it relevant or of any real import.
  6. The books never mention any cult of dragon caretakers but their existence is a cool addition to the lore of the universe. It definitely makes sense that the original Targaryens who fled Valyria would bring a large retinue of people who knew how to raise and feed dragons. Rhaenyra losing their support could be looked at as a really bad sign for the future.
  7. The last shot of the episode, as shown below, has Rhaenyra and Syrax standing in front of Vermithor and Silverwing. Syrax is the offspring of these 2 dragons, so we get a nice little family reunion.
Rhaenyra and Cyrax, Hugh Hammer and Vermithor, and Ulf the White and Silverwing

Stray Observations:

  1. The title “The Red Sowing” is a direct homage to the book, as this was the name given to the massacre of dragonseeds when they attempted to claim dragons.
  2. I loved that Addam wanted help learning High Valyrian from Rhaenyra. How could anyone control a dragon without being able to say Dohaeris?
  3. It seems unfair to blame the Kingsguard for the riot started last episode. I interpreted this as just an excuse for Aemond to remove Kingsguard members who were loyal to his brother.
  4. Corlys had to work quickly to assuage the rest of the council on Addam’s loyalty as a dragonrider. If only he just mentioned he was his father.
  5. Simon Strong’s facial expressions to Daemon as Oscar gave his speech were incredible. “Please don’t kill everyone here buddy”
  6. The detail of the fish scales on Oscar’s armor were fantastic. Appropriate since the sigil of the Tullys is a fish.
  7. Alyn saying he is “of salt and sea” is the exact phrasing used by Baela a few episodes back to Corlys when he asked her to be his heir. Very subtle foreshadowing here.
  8. Poor Ulf, it isn’t fair he has to go to Dragonstone with his leg injury.
  9. The scene of Alicent walking to the water and swimming felt very Lord of the Rings-esque to me, especially the sore.
  10. Rhaenyra’s speech to the dragonseeds came off as extremely culty.
  11. Huge difference in the way Hugh and Ulf claimed their dragons. One by showing strength, the other by showing pure submission.

RIP: Ser Willem Blackwood. A lot of peasants that thought they had Targaryen blood

Season 2-Episode 06

Smallfolk

It is my fault, I think, that you have forgotten to fear me

Rhaenyra Targaryen

Observations from a Book Reader

  1. It is mentioned several times throughout GRRM’s books that lions were once actually native to the Westerlands. However, at the time of Game of Thrones it was apparent most were extinct. Not sure why the Lannister army here travels with lions, I can’t imagine they are very helpful in battle.
  2. Otto Hightower, before being dismissed, was the one to reach out to the Triarchy for an alliance, not Aemond. Aemond also never attempted to put Otto back into his old position as Hand. Otto was still in King’s Landing throughout all these events, but once dismissed by Aegon he never returned to such a high rank.
  3. Ser Steffon Darklyn was one of many dragonseeds to die trying to claim a dragon for the Blacks. He was one of the few knights fully loyal to Rhaenyra, and was actually the person who managed to smuggle Jaehaerys’ crown out of the Red Keep when fleeing the Greens. His loss was regarded as a major blow to Rhaenyra.
  4. The book was inconclusive on the parentage of Addam and Alyn, and most believed they were the bastard children of Laenor, Corlys’ son. This always seemed unlikely due to Laenor’s preference for men, and the show is now explicit about Corlys being their father. Something else to note, Corlys as a Velaryon has Targaryen blood from various generations of marriages between the 2 families. This would mean Addam and Alyn also have the blood of the dragon.
  5. The large dragon in the Vale was known as Sheepstealer. This original name came (obviously) from the dragon’s diet after migrating from the caves around Dragonstone to the food rich lands of the vale during the Dance of the Dragons. The show is heavily implying that Rhaena will attempt to bond with this dragon, but in the book it was a “commonborn” girl named Nettles. Nettles seems to be written off the show like many other characters. More on her later.
  6. The books make it clear that a dragon will never bond with someone while their rider still lives. We know Laenor is still alive in the show, so Seasmoke bonding with Laenor’s half brother Addam indicates that if enough time or distance passes, the bond between dragon and rider is severed. Or that the show-runners forgot about this tiny piece of lore.
  7. Mysaria and Rhaenyra never became romantically attached. Mysaria continued working in the shadows on behalf of Rhaenyra as her mistress of whisperers. Knowing Rhaenyra in the show is now openly hooking up with Mysaria does give some credence to the season 1 theories that Rhaenyra and Alicent had romantic feelings for one another.
Nettles and Sheepstealer. Art by Jota Saraiva

Other Points to Notice

  1. In the beginning of the season, Alicent protested Aemond’s seat on the council. Now with Aemond in power, he is the one who dismisses his mother from her own seat. So far the subtitle of this season could be “Alicent suffers from the consequences of her own actions”.
  2. Both visions that Daemon has of his brother Viserys relate to the same incident. The death of Viserys’ wife Aemma and son Baelon. This adds fuel to the theory that all of these visions are related to the guilt Daemon feels for his past actions. We know that he deep down loved his brother, so the fact that he was too busy making jokes about the “heir for a day” in taverns instead of being there for Viserys weighs on him. Is the whole purpose of this arc supposed to be Alys Rivers using magic to help Daemon gain a conscience?
  3. The sphere Aemond puts into Aegon’s hand was the one that represented Aegon’s seat at the council table. Each member seems to have their own unique one, since we saw Aemond move his to a different spot upon being named regent. Giving Aegon his old one back was Aemond’s not so subtle way of telling Aegon he would never be able to sit at the head of the table again. Aegon seemed to understand this when he claimed to not remember how he was burnt.
  4. House Beesbury is mentioned as going to war against the Hightowers in The Reach. In season 1, Lyman Beesbury was the man on the small council who was openly in favor of crowning Rhaenyra queen once Viserys died, and was immediately killed by Cole. His family is now coming after the Hightowers as revenge.
  5. The smallfolk riot against Alicent and Helaena was reminiscent of the riot in season 2 of Game of Thrones against Joffrey and Cersei. During that riot Sansa Stark was only saved because of the interference of the Hound, just as Alicent and Helaena are only saved because of the heavily armored Kingsguard.
Brotherly love

Stray Observations:

  1. We finally get a new opening credits scene. This one shows Sunfyre and Meleys lying dead on the ground, with Aemond raising his sword in the middle of the corpses. Is Sunfyre actually dead??
  2. The reaction from the council to Alicent refusing to marry a Greyjoy was incredible. “Man, it sure would be nice if you did marry him though!”.
  3. Steffon Darklyn could not have been more excited to get burnt by Seasmoke.
  4. The dragon caretaker who slit his own throat while on fire deserved better. What a legend.
  5. It’s hard to tell if Ulf was just a stooge in Mysaria’s plot to get the smallfolk to turn on the Greens, or if he was also acting alongside the woman talking about the feasts the royals were having.
  6. Rhaenyra slapping Lord Celtigar felt like a desperate way to regain control. She really has not done much to help her cause so far.
  7. Jace really is not enjoying the way his mother is running the show
  8. Gwayne did a great job in letting Alicent know the only son of hers she did not directly raise, ended up being the best of all of her children.
  9. Hugh Hammer immediately decided to beat a random peasant for all his food.
  10. Addam didn’t claim Seasmoke. Seasmoke claimed him.

RIP: Ser Steffon Darklyn and the random guy who burned next to him.

Season 1-Episode 06

The Princess and the Queen

The wise sailor flees the storm as it gathers

Laenor Velaryon

Major Plot Points: Rhaenyra gives birth and has to deal with gossip. Alicent accidentally plots a murder. Daemon becomes single once again. Criston talks a lot of shit.

Observations from a Book Reader:

  1. The title of the episode is a reference to a 2013 novella written by GRRM for the anthology book Dangerous Women. This novella told the story of the Dance of the Dragons for the first time and it was fleshed out more in another short story called The Rogue Prince before both were combined and given even more details in Fire and Blood.
  2. Laenor was white with blonde hair in the book. Rhaenyra having 3 brown haired kids was still looked at suspiciously by the rest of the kingdom, but it wasn’t quite as obvious her children were bastards as it is in the show. I think this change makes a lot of sense, as it is a clear visual sign to the audience what is going on. Especially when we see that Laena and Daemon’s children are black with white hair.
  3. The dragon that scares Aemond in the dragonpit, is Dreamfyre, originally ridden by Rhaena Targaryen, grand-daughter of Aegon the Conqueror. We also heard in Episode 2that the eggs Daemon stole were from Dreamfyre.
  4. We see Laena riding the gigantic dragon Vhagar, the last of the remaining 3 dragons from when Aegon the Conqueror arrived. As a child, Laena found and tamed Vhagar, surprising everyone as Vhagar had not accepted a rider in years. Sadly, the scene of her doing so was cut from the show, even though in an earlier episode Vhagar’s status was discussed.
  5. Before marrying Daemon, Laena was betrothed to a son of the Sea Lord of Braavos. Daemon antagonized him while visiting Driftmark, and got him angry enough to duel. Daemon slew him with ease, and married Laena a few days later. This did not cause too much of an uproar, as the man who was killed was by all accounts, an arrogant prick.
  6. It is unknown if Rhaenyra’s children were able to discern their true parentage in the book. I have to think that they figured it out but knew enough to never discuss it, as their lives would almost certainly be forfeit if it came out.
  7. The death of Lyonel and Harwin Strong at Harrenhal was a subject of great controversy. Instead of knowing who was responsible, the book just gave a list of suspects, including Corlys Velaryon, who was theorized to have killed the man that made made a cuckold of his son. Turns out it was Larys the whole time. With his father and brother dead, he is now the Lord of Harrenhal, but the sick part is he probably does not care about that at all. For him, this was a simple way to force Alicent into his debt, as it would bring her father back into the game, and take care of the problem with Rhaenyra’s almost public affair with Harwin. Littlefinger was a sociopath but Larys seems to be even more monstrous so far.
The Fall of Harrenhal. Aegon the Conqueror melted half of the castle, killing Lord Harren, the original owner. This event is what began what came to be known as the curse of Harrenhal

Other Points to Notice

  1. The opening scene is something we had not seen from this show or Game of Thrones before. 2 long continues takes from the birth of Joffrey to Rhaenyra getting to her father’s room. There is also a distinct lack of background music that adds to the “realness” of the scenario
  2. Harwin Strong is now the Lord Commander of the City Watch (The police of King’s Landing who wear gold cloaks). While we find out for sure later in the episode, this scene makes it very clear there is a relationship between Rhaenyra and Harwin.
  3. Alicent’s reaction to Criston calling Rhaenyra a cunt is telling. Criston is a full on angry spurned lover at this point and he truly hates her. Alicent is more so just worried and upset about the damage Rhaenyra is doing by siring bastards. She is correct, as brazenly presenting bastards, if found out, would cause House Velaryon to rebel and surely cause a war. She is also now fully on board with putting Aegon on the throne over Rhaenyra, as she tells her son himself. It’s important to remember a big motivation for Alicent is her belief that her children will be killed if Rhaenyra takes the throne, either by Rhaenyra or her supporters.
  4. Criston does a great job of exposing Harwin in the practice yard, as Harwin’s brutal reaction only makes sense if Jacaerys is in fact his son. It seems like Criston really only does it to be spiteful. He hates Rhaenyra so much at this point that he also hates her children. Harwin attacking Criston is reminiscent of last episode when Criston killed Joffrey. Harwin is obviously punished far more for it, since Criston is a member of the Kingsguard and therefore regarded as “untouchable”.
  5. The small council meeting appears to be a total disaster. The rift between Rhaenyra and Alicent is almost as bad as the divide between the 2 houses they were discussing, the Brackens and Blackwoods. Lyman Beesbury, the master of coin, seems to be totally senile and can’t follow the conversation. And then Rhaenyra tries to marry her son to Alicent’s daughter. This would have legitimized Rhaenyra’s claim to the throne and united both sides of the family in the succession. Alicent would never agree to this though, as she believes that Jacaerys is a bastard, and that her son Aegon should be on the throne.
  6. The sigil on Larys’ walking stick that we see when he enters the dungeon, as well as the sigils placed on the mute criminals he employs, is that of a bee, and not that of House Strong. There is a quote about Larys in the book, “The words dripped from his lips like honey from a comb, and never did poison taste so sweet.” His bee sigil could be a reference to that quote, and just as Littlefinger discarded his family sigil for a mockingbird, perhaps Larys is discarding his family sigil for the bee. Which would be a pretty direct message to the audience that Larys is going to be the Littlefinger of this series.
  7. Unlike his brother, Daemon was much less willing to throw Laena’s life away for a c-section. He may have decided on it eventually, but Laena quickly left the situation to end things on her own terms, which was an incredibly cool way to go out.
Laena Targaryen going out like a legend

Stray Observations:

  1. It’s nice to see that Laenor and Rhaenyra have a close relationship, if not a romantic one. But it is also hilarious that it’s the only healthy relationship in this series.
  2. King Viserys is like 50 in the books at this point. I can’t decide if the show-runners aged him up, or they made him look this way just to show how ill he is.
  3. Let’s take a second and name every Targaryen kid. Rhaenyra’s sons: Jacaerys (Jace), Lucerys (Luke), and newborn Joffrey. Alicent’s children: Aegon, Helaena, Aemond, and Daeron. Daeron was not in this episode which means he either was not born yet, or the show is cutting his character. In which case I just gave a completely pointless name to anyone reading this who probably already had Targaryen name overload.
  4. The Valyria model Viserys is working on actually looks cool at this point.
  5. It’s nice to know that Viserys is an expert on dominant/recessive genes due to his time owning a horse.
  6. It does seem like Daemon truly cares for his wife and daughters. But he also appears really depressed. I don’t think domestic life is for this guy.
  7. Am I crazy, or when Emma D’Arcy (Rhaenyra) speaks her mouth movement is similar to Lena Headey as Cersei sometimes?
  8. Daemon and Laena’s 2 twin daughters are named Baela and Rhaena.
  9. The shot of Laena being burned alive by her beloved dragon, combined with the music and follow up shot of Daemon observing it, was the scene of the episode for me.
  10. As Larys said, the Strong deaths were easy to sell to the realm, because almost all the people in Westeros believed that Harrenhal was cursed. Ever since it was built, the house that controlled it met eerie and grim deaths. It is the Westeros equivalent of the Defense Against the Dark Art’s Professor curse in Harry Potter.

RIP: Laena Velaryon, Ser Harwin “Breakbones” Strong, Lord Lyonel Strong

Season 8-Episode 06

Episode 73: The Iron Throne

“What unites people? Army? Gold? Flags? Stories. There’s nothing in the world more powerful than a good story. Nothing can stop it. No enemy can defeat it.”

Major Plot Points: Daenerys finally achieves her goal.  Jon sacrifices love for duty.  Tyrion gets a new job.  Bran wins.  Sansa gets her kingdom. Arya sails to discover the West Indies.

Observations from a Book Reader:

  1. GRRM claims that the show’s ending will closely mirror his own book ending.  With that said, there will still be significant differences, and I am sure he will get us to the end in a way that feels more natural. 
  2. Daenerys never saw a vision of the Iron Throne in a destroyed castle.  This was a show-only addition to her visions in the House of the Undying, and she re-enacted it this episode as she approached the the throne.
  3. The Grand Maester is known as the personal Maester to the King, and is also regarded as the wisest and most senior of all the Maesters.  Obviously, Sam gets the job, but it really seems like he cut the line a bit. While he does have experiences that no other Maester  could dream of, I still don’t know if I can believe that the Arch-Maesters in the Citadel would allow this to happen.
  4. Westeros wass always called “The Seven Kingdoms” but at this point, it’s more like 9.  The Iron Islands and the Riverlands used to be 1 kingdom (The Kingdom of the Isles and Rivers), and an additional region, the Crownlands, was added by Aegon Targaryen when he conquered Westeros.  So with the North gone, it would technically be the 8 Kingdoms.
  5. Dorne was the last kingdom to kneel to the Targaryens.  If the North were to secede, then it is likely the Dornish would not be far behind.  So much distance separates these 2 kingdoms from King’s Landing, that being included in the Seven Kingdoms was really only a formality. 

Other Points to Notice

  1. While it may seem a bit unrealistic that Tyrion was able to find his sibling’s bodies in the rubble, I am going to give the writers some artistic license, just for the fact that we get to see Tyrion really understand what his actions in following Dany have led to.  It did seem like the whole basement collapsed last episode though.
  2. In her heart, Dany truly believed that she was liberating the common people from the Lannisters.  The men and women in King’s Landing were not innocent to her, and she saw it as a necessary evil in killing them.  In her last scene with Jon, we see that she hasn’t changed into an evil madwoman overnight. Disturbingly, she still seems pretty much the same.  She even tells Jon that the two of them know what is right, and they don’t have to worry about other people’s opinions on the matter. It was at that moment that Jon knew she would never see reason.
  3. Jon being a Targaryen ended up being a major contributor to his tragic downfall.  It drove a wedge in between him and Daenerys, and it gave Sansa the perfect weapon to destroy Dany’s inner circle.  Because of his honest nature, this secret that Ned spent his entire life trying to keep, ended up pushing Daenerys over the edge.  Jealous of his claim, and worried about her advisors betraying her, she was driven to using fear as her primary method of leadership.  I believe that if Jon never knew about his true parents, or at the very least, never told Sansa/Dany, King’s Landing would not have burned.  Jon also had to pay for his honesty, by spending the rest of his life as an exile.
  4. Tyrion’s speech to Jon was by far my favorite part of the episode  “Everywhere she goes, evil men die, and we cheer her for it. And she grows more powerful and more sure that she is good and right. She believes her destiny is to build a better world for everyone. If you believed that, truly believed it, wouldn’t you kill whoever stood between you and paradise?”  In a way, Tyrion is both talking to Jon, and the viewers of the show.  Looking back it does put Dany’s story in a different perspective.  But it wasn’t until Tyrion brought up Jon’s sisters, that Jon actually realized what he had to do.
  5. Drogon choosing not to kill Jon may be simply due to Jon being a Targaryen.  It was always stated how the Targaryens were the only ones who could calm dragons.  And while it was a bit campy that Drogon destroyed the throne, I did appreciate the symbolism.  It was the throne, and the desire for power that killed Daenerys, just as much as Jon.  A better writer than me once proposed that the Iron Throne was nothing more than GRRM’s version of the One Ring of Power from Lord of the Rings, and it’s impossible to dispute that fact now.
  6. Bran as King makes sense, since he really would be the wisest and least biased person to rule.  But I really wish we saw more examples of him using his powers for constructive purposes before this sudden change.  Even in the small council scene (worst scene of the episode BY FAR) he merely smirks and rolls off before we can see his judgement in any real matters.  Also, the idea of a council picking a new ruler whenever an old one dies seems like it could have a really bad ending. 
  7. Brienne writing Jaime’s entry in the White Book of the Kingsguard is a nice cap to his story.  In season 4 we saw Joffrey ridicule him for his entry only talking about killing the Mad King.  At least now he leaves behind some sort of a legacy.  Also I guess this means that Brienne is the Lord of the Kingsguard now?
  8. In season 6, when Arya was under the care of the actress, Lady Crane, she tells Crane that her dream is to one day sail west of Westeros.  At least she is consistent. 
  9. I assume that the new Night’s Watch is basically just the new Westerosi prison.  They obviously have no wildlings or White Walkers to look out for now, so I cant imagine they have much to do.  Thankfully we got to see Jon reunite with Ghost and actually pet him this time.  Some believe that Jon becomes King-Beyond-the-Wall, but I don’t think he would ever want that.  I think he spends the rest of his life exploring the north, and enjoying his rest.  With the Night King and Dany dead, he really has nothing left to fight for.  He was the Frodo of this story, sacrificing his own happiness and a normal life, to save the kingdom. 
  10. I really wish we got to see Yara react to her brother’s death. Also are we supposed to assume the Iron Islands are going to be cool with the “no reaving/pillaging” policy Dany once made them swear?

Stray Observations:

  1. With Jaime and Cersei dead, I guess that means Tyrion is the Lord of Casterly Rock?
  2. Grey Worm really acts like a dick. (get it?)
  3. Loved the shot of Daenerys with dragon wings behind her.
  4. This is the first time in years we hear Tyrion speak about killing Shae.
  5. Tyrion clearly read my blog, he brought up the same points I did about Dany killing mass groups of people.
  6. Every woman that Jon has ever slept with, ends up dead in his arms.
  7. Dany says she imagined a throne too high to climb.  That pretty much describes what the throne looks like in the books.
  8. Eagle eyed viewers believe that the man sitting next to Edmure Tully, is none other than Howland Reed, Meera and Jojen’s father.
  9. Classic dumb Edmure.  I really could have done without all the fucking gags this episode.  Edmure stubbing his toe, everyone laughing at Sam’s democracy pitch, and the brothel gag in the small council room really deflated the mood.
  10. We still never hear the end of Tyrion’s jackass and honeycomb joke. Third time was not the charm

RIP: Queen Daenerys Targaryen; Stormborn; Breaker of Chains; The Unburnt; Khaleesi of the Great Grass Sea; Mother of Dragons; Queen of Meereen; Queen of the Seven Kingdoms; Protector of the Realm; Queen of the Andals, the Rhoynar and the First Men; Lady of Dragonstone.

Things I Liked:  Jaime and Theon had great resolutions to their arcs, even though Jaime’s was super rushed at the end.  I also like how Jon did not end up sitting on the throne, it wouldn’t have made sense for him.  Sansa as Queen in the North is also a nice touch, but it seems the Starks really came out as the ultimate winners in the end.

Things I Did Not Like: The Long Night had too many death fake-out moments for my taste.  I understand that the Night King had to lose at that point, but there really should have been more consequences for it.  Daenerys also was painted in a worse light than she deserved.  Her burning King’s Landing may have been inevitable, but we could have gotten there in a more natural way with more time. Everything with Euron sucked.  Really my biggest complaint about this season is insane, and uneven pacing.  Almost every narrative mistake happened because the writers had to bounce characters around with no regard for realism, and had to rush arcs that we barely had time to digest.  And why was Sam not in the crypts the whole time?

It’s finally over.  After a decade of watching, reading, and arguing on Reddit, Game of Thrones is finally done.  This last season was certainly divisive, but I think in the end I did like the broad plot points, just not really how we got to them.  The writers seemed to acknowledge this problem in the series finale, and used Tyrion and Dany as mouthpieces to speak to the audience on why things were happening the way they were. Both Tyrion telling us why we should have known Dany would kill all those people, and Dany explaining to Jon how through her judgement alone without any other voices, the world could be unified, seemed to be spoken directly to viewers.  I suspect in years from now people will enjoy these last few episodes more, but for now the rushed nature of it all skews things in an unfavorable light. I’ll see you all next year when I restart this blog to cover the spinoffs

Season 8-Episode 05

Episode 72: The Bells

“I hope I deserve this. Truly I do. I hope I’m wrong. Goodbye old friend.”

Major Plot Points: Daenerys breaks bad.  Jaime and Cersei reunite. Cleganebowl. Jon is sad. I am sad.

Observations from a Book Reader:

  1. One of the main reasons Aerys was known as the Mad King, was due to the way he would imagine enemies at every corner.  He always suspected people of treason, even his own son Rhaegar.  Daenerys shows these symptons as well when she begins interrogating Tyrion about who betrayed her.  She assumes everyone is now against her.
  2. Varys has spent his whole life planning to put Aegon on the throne (book only character from Essos).  He never was a Daenerys supporter.  He likes Aegon for the same reasons he likes Jon in the show, he sees him as someone born to rule, with the right temperament to make hard decisions.
  3. When Aerys was convinced to open the gates of King’s Landing to Tywin Lannister, the city was completely wrecked.  Known as the Sack of King’s Landing, thousands of innocent people were killed and raped by Lannister and Northern forces.  At the end of it, when Ned saw Tywin present to Robert the bloody corpses of Rhaegar’s infant children, he was so disgusted by the whole ordeal that he stormed out, and did not talk to Robert again until 6 years later during the Greyjoy Rebellion.
  4. This ending is supposedly in line with GRRM’s.  In the books, through Dany’s POV it becomes much easier to see this happening.  She was always absolutely hellbent on the throne and came off as very head strong the entire time.  While in the desert with Drogon after flying from the Fighting Pits, she even begins hallucinating, an event that helped book readers begin theorizing about a new Mad Queen of Westeros.
  5. Cersei always believed Tyrion would kill her, due to the prophecy she heard as a child that said “When your tears have drowned you, the valonqar  (means little brother) shall wrap his hands about your pale white throat and choke the life from you.”  Jaime was also her younger brother, so fans believed this meant he would kill her.  But in the end, he did wrap his hands around her throat as they both died.  Prophecies are always a bit fucky.

Other Points to Notice

  1. Varys asks his child spy about Daenerys, specifically if she’s been eating yet.  It is very possible he is using this girl, who works in the kitchens, to attempt to poison her.  This is reinforced by the way he says “The greater the risk, the greater the reward.”  It was a tough sell to get Jon in on his treason though.  If he really knew Jon, he would know this attempt was futile.
  2. It does seem abrupt that Daenerys has gone this far into “madness”. With a few more episodes to show the transition, it would have made more sense.  But the pieces were there for us to pick up on.  In interviews, Emilia Clarke explained that in Dany’s head, all of the people who actually cared about her were dead, and the ones remaining had done nothing but hurt her cause. She lost Jorah, Missandei, her 2 dragons, and her relationship with Jon.  She had nothing to lose, and no reason to show any mercy to anyone.  She brings up this lack of love with Jon. Fear is all she has.
  3. When I first saw Tyrion letting Jaime go, I was pretty upset at what I thought was an idiotic move.  But then he began telling Jaime his real reason for it, and it all made sense.  Tyrion knew he would be killed for it, but he also knew he had to save the one person in the entire world who ever actually loved him.  I am positive that he knew Jaime would not be able to get Cersei to stand down, but he did it anyway.  It was an touching moment between the two brothers, and the last one they’d ever share.
  4. I have no qualms with how easily Drogon destroyed the scorpions, or the Iron Fleet.  He is a fucking dragon.  But it does make it really dumb how easily they were able to kill Rhaegal with pinpoint accuracy.  How much better would it be if the Iron Fleet killed Rhaegal through some sort of trickery, and not an ludicrous snipe shot. 
  5. Daeneyrs wins the battle easily.  As she hears the bells, she looks at the Red Keep, and there she is reminded of all the things Cersei, and this city in general, have done to her and her family.  It was not enough for her to just win, she wanted to annihilate everyone there. 
  6. When looking back through the series, this brutality from Daenerys is something that was always there, hidden beneath the surface.  In S1, she calmly watched as her brother’s skull melted, and her dragons only hatched after she burned a woman alive.  In S2, she tells the masters of Qaarth she will one day burn cities to the ground.  S3 shows her completely burn alive all the masters of Yunkai, and her Unsullied massacre even more.  S4 she crucifies 100 other people, some who did nothing against her.  S6 she burns all the Dothraki Khals alive.  Generally in later seasons, she always wanted to take the path of violence, but was talked down from it by her advisors and close friends who kept her grounded.  She never outright murdered innocent people, but to her the people of King’s Landing were not innocent. Obviously, this is no excuse for her actions, but it does help explain this horrible turn of events.  As an audience we always rooted for her when she killed groups of people, and now that it happens to a city we are invested in, we see just how terrible it can be when a dragon is led into battle by someone trying to conquer.
  7. Jon does not do much this episode, except watch in horror as his men attacked civilians.  Grey Worm however, seems to lose all empathy for his fellow men. He burned Missandei’s collar, and with that lost the rest of his humanity.
  8. The Jaime and Euron scene served no purpose at all.  Jaime died with Cersei anyway.  Euron should have died on the boat. Waste of time
  9. The show did an incredible job with making the Cleganebowl an actual meaningful battle.  The Hound was able to convince Arya that the path of vengeance is a disease, something he learned from his late Septon friend in Season 6.  Arya then departs the Red Keep, trying to help everyone she can, but not before she thanks Sandor and even calls him by his real name.  I believe she is finally ready to move on.  And the fight between the Hound and the Mountain is perfect. I liked how the Mountain was shown to still have some of his old self inside, since he became hyper-focused on killing his brother. 
  10. It’s a bit strange that Arya is in King’s Landing at all, but her journey through the streets is filmed so well that I didn’t even care.  Through her eyes we see the actual devastation of the battle, and she tries to save a mother and child even as she is terrified.  The white horse she finds could also symbolize her taking the righteous path, by leaving her anger and revenge behind her as she gallops out of the city. But who knows, she may kill Dany next episode.
  11. Jaime was on a path of redemption from Season 3 onwards.  But in the end, even though he did grow immensely as a person, he chose to be with Cersei in her last moments.  Some wanted Cersei to be killed by Jaime, but that act of violence would have been a rough ending to a character we saw grow into a better person throughout the series.  Jaime’s story ends in truly tragic fashion, he was so close to finally shedding his past. It doesn’t negate the good things he did though, especially his choice to fight the Night King’s army.
Cleganebowl. I was justifiably hyped.

Stray Observations:

  1. I loved how calm Varys was about his execution. He burned the evidence and removed his rings.  He was ready for this moment his entire life.
  2. The shot of Drogon emerging from the shadows was one of my favorites.
  3. If Jon just made out with Dany a little harder, many people would have lived.
  4. This season is the best acting Emilia Clarke has ever done. She kills every single scene.
  5. We absolutely did not need the slapstick comedy scene where Tyrion tried speaking Valyrian to the Unsullied.
  6. Lmfao at the Golden Company.
  7. Some were surprised the “honorable” northern soldiers engaged in rape, but way back in season 2 northern soldiers attempted to rape Brienne.  They were just as violent as the Lannister Soldiers.
  8. The shot of the Mountain looking down at the Hound as a dragon flies over. Are you kidding me?  I need that poster yesterday.
  9. Cersei was one of the best villains in tv/movie history, and Lena Headey deserves unlimited praise for it.
  10. The sad rendition of the Rains of Castamere playing as Jaime and Cersei died was a stroke of brilliance by the show’s composer, Ramin Djawadi

RIP: Varys. Homeless Harry Strickland.  Ser Jaime Lannister, the Kingslayer.  Queen Cersei Lannister.  Euron Greyjoy.  Gregor Clegane.  Sandor Clegane.  Qyburn. 

Season 8-Episode 04

Episode 71: The Last of the Starks

“I would murder every woman and child for her. She’s hateful, and so am I”

Major Plot Points: Daenerys heads south.  Jon gossips with his sisters.  Euron hides in plain sight.  Cersei looks down on her enemies.

Observations from a Book Reader:

  1. Jon calling the fallen soldiers “the shield that guards the realms of men” is of course a direct callback to the oath every member of the Night’s Watch takes.  In fact, if you pretend Jon is giving this speech at a Castle Black funeral, it still really works.  He basically just recycles a eulogy he probably heard a million times before.
  2. Stannis is still technically the Lord of Storm’s End.  But Aegon (the potentially fake Aegon from Essos) and the Golden Company now hold it. 
  3. There are many theories about what Bran will do once he is the Three Eyed Raven.  Will he use his new powers to manipulate the politics of Westeros? I am certain he will have a larger part to play than just revealing Jon’s true parentage.
  4. Sansa and the Hound have an even weirder past together.  When he approached her to leave King’s Landing with him, he drunkenly kissed her.
  5. The Prince of Dorne is still Doran Martell.  If he died, it would go to his daughter Arianne.  Since she is out of the show, I have no idea at all who this new prince could be.  Possibly someone from another house, like the Daynes. 
  6. Bronn is correct about the origin of great houses.  The Lannisters became a major house because their ancestor, Lann the Clever, stole Casterly Rock from the Casterlys.
  7. Ballista crossbows exist, but they wouldn’t work against a dragon.

Other Points to Notice

  1. We see Daenerys whisper something into Jorah’s ear.  According to Ian Glenn, it was a very personal message from Emilia Clarke that he says was extremely touching.
  2. Tyrion and Davos have a interesting conversation about the Lord of Light.  They both acknowledge that he does probably exist, but they have the same questions we do.  Is he still around? Was his only role in this story to defeat the White Walkers?
  3. Tyrion comes off slightly cruel in his drinking game with Brienne.  More in line with book Tyrion, in the show he is usually not as much of a dick.
  4. Daenerys begins feeling increasingly isolated.  She sees everyone celebrate Jon riding a dragon and defeating the White Walkers, both things she also did.   It makes sense why she grows increasingly hostile as the episode progresses, the goals she has worked her entire life for are being thrown away to someone else just because he’s a dude. 
  5. Kinda weird that the writers decided to make Sansa happy about her experiences.  It almost makes it seem like they were trying to justify the whole “rape” plotline, and it understandably irked some people the wrong way.
  6. You can see the desperation in Dany when she begs Jon to keep his lineage a secret.  She is entirely correct, even if Jon claims he does not want the throne, his family and the North would never let him abdicate.  Even honorable Ned Stark understood this, and never told his wife about it.  Also Sansa tells Tyrion immediately.
  7. I wish there was a scene between Arya and Sansa after Jon reveals his secret to them.  I’d like to see their reactions, plus Arya goes from saying how much her family means to her, to leaving Winterfell immediately.  It was really sudden to me.
  8. The scene with Bronn is hard to believe.  I can stomach him sneaking into Winterfell I guess, but what was the purpose of this conversation? He just takes their word that he will get Highgarden? This seems to me like a plot-line created just to get Bronn in one last scene with the Lannister boys. 
  9. Sansa knew exactly what she was doing by telling Tyrion about Jon.  She is planting the seed to sow discord in Dany’s court, a very Littlefinger move.
  10. It’s very possible this episode shows us certain characters for the last time, like Gendry, Sam and Gilly.  Tormund however could be back, and he left it open that one day Jon may return to the true North.
  11. It is unlikely Euron was able to hide an entire fleet and catch Rhaegal unaware.  I get why he would be waiting in the waters near Dragonstone, but the show could have done a more realistic job of depicting his fleet being hidden from an airborne Daenerys. 
  12. For all his talk about “helping the realm” Varys really flip flops his allegiances constantly, which ultimately hurts the realm.  Daenerys is rightfully upset at losing her 2 closest friends, her 2 dragons, and her potential happiness with Jon.  Any normal person would be angry at this point, and Varys just blames it on her being mad.  I could be wrong here, and we will see soon, but Dany hasn’t as of yet done anything to justify Varys leaving.
  13. Jaime and Brienne getting together is something that was years in the making.  They both clearly had feelings for each other, and it was nice to see them come to terms with it.  But then we see Jaime leave her, to go back to Cersei.  When I first watched, I thought he was leaving to go kill Cersei, but now I believe he is going back because he feels that he does not deserve the new life and redemption he found in Brienne.  In the end, his story will be about how close he actually came to becoming a better person, but failed just when he got there.  This story would have been a lot better if it were spread out over the course of a season, and not over 20 minutes, but here we are.   RIP Jaime.
  14. Did anyone really think Tyrion would convince Cersei to stand down?  Also I wish that Dany’s armies were not so close to the ballista, because it would be in character for Cersei to have her men shoot at them.
The arid desert outside of King’s Landing

 Stray Observations:

  1. The title confuses me a bit.  The Starks didn’t lose anyone this episode.
  2. Theon finally got that Stark swag he always wanted.
  3. The Hound was able to *sniff* out Gendry’s intentions with Arya very quickly
  4. Arya shot Gendry down harder than Euron shot Rhaegal down.  I saw that on twitter unfortunately its not an original. 
  5. Sansa could have been a bit kinder to Daenerys in the council room. She really hates her.
  6. At least we got Arya and the Hound together one more time.
  7. Glad they brought Ghost back for an unceremonious goodbye.  I mean how much more money would it cost for Jon to go pet him. God damn it.
  8. Poor Brienne.
  9. Qyburn walking out from King’s Landing reminds me of the Mouth of Sauron emerging from the Black Gates in Return of the King to negotiate with Aragorn. 
  10. Missandei’s last words are up there with my favorite from the show. She basically tell Dany to kill all her enemies.

RIP: Rhaegal, and Missandei of Narth.

Season 8-Episode 03

Episode 70: The Long Night

“Theon. You’re a good man. Thank you.”

Major Plot Points: Jon yells at a dragon.  Dany uses a sword.  Sam cowers.  Arya does her spooky assassin thing. Theon Greyjoy kills Reek.

Observations from a Book Reader:

  1. The episode title describes the battle, but it also references the first fight against the White Walkers thousands of years ago.  Called “The Long Night” or “The War for the Dawn”, the Children of the Forest and the First Men joined together to push back the White Walkers.  Presumably the Wall was built shortly after.
  2. The Long Night is also where the legend of Azor Ahai comes from.  He of course was the mythical hero of the Lord of Light, and it was foretold he would one day be reborn.  Mel once thought Stannis was Azor Ahai.  After this episode, I think that the prophecy was always kind of a bait and switch.
  3. Thoros was able to light Beric’s sword on fire, and Mel did the same with Stannis’ sword.  But in this show Beric can light his like a lightsaber, and Melisandre lights about 500 Dothraki blades at once.  It gives an incredible affect when you see them turn off one by one, but it does seem a tad overpowered. How could anyone not believe in the Lord of Light after this?
  4. The White Walkers are able to bring winter storms with them wherever they go, and utilized this tactic well against the Night’s Watch at the Fist of the First Men.
  5. The Night King does not exist, and the White Walker’s motivations are completely unknown.  If the next books come out, I really hope we get more explanations into their conquest of Westeros. 
  6. Azor Ahai reborn will probably end up being a combination of Daenerys and Jon.  Or neither.

Other Points to Notice

  1. While I am glad that Melisandre made an appearance, I think they could have had her arrive at the end of last week.  It seems a bit strange she is able to appear right in front of the undead army. 
  2. Jorah being one of the only people to return from the front lines seems like an unnecessary flaunt of plot armor.  Obviously he dies later in the episode, so why send him out there at all?  Characters living through battles is a mainstay of thrones, but putting them in ludicrous situations where they have no right to survive seems like nothing more than stirring up fake dramatic tension.  This episode has quite a bit of that. 
  3. Sansa entering the crypts with the women and children is very similar to her entering Maegor’s Holdfast with Cersei during the Battle of the Blackwater.  She demonstrated leadership skills there by getting all the women and children to join her in singing a hymn.  Apparently there were cut scenes in this episode of her calming the people in the crypts as well. 
  4.  Jon does not do much during this battle.  He could have at least used Rhaegal to light the trench on fire.
  5. Arya’s library scene is probably the best display of her non-lethal assassin skills we get.  If anyone is able to sneak up on the Night King in the entire world, it’s her.
  6. Hard not to make the blatant (somewhat on-the-nose) connection between Beric with his arms up against the doorframe, and Jesus dying on the cross.  Beric even dies so Arya can live.  Melisandre tells this to Arya, and reminds her of all the “blue” eyes she will shut.  This is enough to make Arya realize what her true purpose in this battle is.
  7. In the Season 7 episode Beyond the Wall, Drogon leaves a huge trail of dragon fire on the ground.  The Night King walks through it without any problem.  Because of this, we knew there was no chance of him dying to dragon fire
  8. Great visual when the Night King brings all his soldiers, and the Winterfell soldiers, back to life.  But it does bring the plot armor issue into light again.  We see simultaneous shots of Jon completely surrounded, and then the next shot he is back in the open.  This happens with Jaime, Brienne, and Tormund too. Again, there is nothing wrong with main characters surviving (the idea of main characters always dying in this show is VASTLY overstated) but it is annoying to see them put in impossible situations they have no chance of overcoming, and then getting through them unscathed.  Main characters living is not new to this series, but these unrealistic situations are way more prevalent in later seasons. 
  9. Drogon surviving all of the undead climbing on him is not a surprise to me.  It takes insane force to pierce a dragon’s scales (Just ask that creepy fuck Qyburn), and lil zombie boys with daggers probably couldn’t do him any real harm.
  10. In the end, no matter how this series ends, I hope people can look back and remember just how incredible of a job both the writers, and Alfie Allen did of portraying Theon’s story.  Best redemption arc I have ever seen.  It ends with him running head first against an opponent that he knows is better than him, and it makes up for him doing the exact opposite against his uncle. Bran even forgives him at the end, which proves that a little piece of Brandon Stark still lives. 
  11. Bran gave Arya that dagger last season.  Fitting the dagger that was once used to almost kill him, ends up being the exact dagger that saves him.  We also see Bran look past the Night King’s shoulder, which makes it seem like he knows Arya is on her way.
  12. The Night King dying 3 episodes before the finale was a huge shocker, but it actually begins to make a lot of sense when you think about it.  GRRM always claims how he finds vanilla “good vs evil” conflicts to be a bit boring.  Obviously, the White Walkers were always built up as the main threat of the show, but the political intrigue and house warfare was what made ASOIAF so unique to begin with.  GRRM also talks about how he enjoyed the post-Sauron LOTR content immensely.  In the books, the hobbits returned to the Shire to find it in ruin, and under the control of Saruman.  They had to use what they learned to overcome this final obstacle.  With 3 episodes left, I expect it to be a similar situation for Jon and Dany.  We have a lot of characters left on the board and for the first time in the entire series, it actually is all about the Iron Throne.  This also makes me feel like we are going to see real conflict between the Starks and Daenerys.  I expect many more actual main characters to die to get to the bittersweet ending. 
  13. For all intents and purposes, the Night King and his army won this battle.  There was no way any of the living characters could escape him here, and Arya was able to use her assassin skills as a hail mary to stop him.   If the Night King doesn’t die during this battle, there is no realistic way he would ever be defeated. 

Stray Observations:

  1. I really don’t understand sending the Dothraki out first.  Seems destined to fail
  2. If Davos executes Melisandre in the beginning of the episode, no shot the human team wins.
  3. Sam spends the whole time on the ground, and gets Edd killed.  He really should have stayed in the crypts, it’s a bit unrealistic he survives the battle the way he does.
  4. Random thought.  I wonder if we will ever see Edmure Tully again.
  5. I really hope Bran was up to some elaborate scheme, and didn’t just warg into ravens for the whole battle.
  6. The Night King gives his giant a weapon.  Why didn’t Jon give Wun-Wun a weapon during the Battle of the Bastards?
  7. We all saw the crypt revival coming, but all named characters surviving seems unfair at best.
  8. Dany really should have taken off with Drogon immediately. 
  9. Sansa and Tyrion pulling out the daggers almost gave me the feeling they were going to kill themselves.  Similar to how Cersei almost poisoned Tommen when she thought Stannis would win the Battle of the Blackwater. 
  10. Incredible music choice for the end of the battle as the Night King slowly walks up to Bran.  We see everyone at their most dire moment, and then bam, Arya attack.
  11. Jon completely gives up in the end, and screams at Viserion.  Poor guy really just wants to rest.
  12. Melisandre, always the exhibitionist, of course dies while taking off her clothes. 
  13. In a way, this episode marks the end of the series.  To me, the rest is the epilogue.  And for once I have no idea what is going to happen next week.

RIP: Theon Greyjoy,  Beric Dondarrion, Jorah Mormont, Lyanna Mormont, “Dolores” Edd Tollett, and Melisandre the Red Woman of Asshai.